Vermont gets a 'D' from Champlain for high school financial literacy

-A A +A

Vermont gets a 'D' from Champlain for high school financial literacy

Wed, 12/13/2017 - 10:00am -- tim

Vermont Business Magazine States are making modest improvements in personal finance education standards, but they still have a long way to go, including Vermont which earned a "D," according to the third report card on state efforts to improve financial literacy in American high schools. John Pelletier, director of the Center for Financial Literacy at Champlain College, which produced the report card, says American high schools have improved incrementally, in part because previous report cards have energized debates and legislation in many states.

Pelletier notes that research from Next Gen Personal Finance indicates that students from wealthy communities are much more likely to have access to personal finance education in high school than students in poor communities. “The poor should have equal access to personal finance education in high school—it shouldn’t be for just the rich,” he says. “But access is only possible if a state policy requires it.”

The report card gives grades to all 50 states and the District of Columbia. You can see all states and their grades in the 2017 report card.

“Americans need to know how to use credit, save for retirement, invest wisely, and understand the many complicated financial decisions made in the average person’s lifetime,” says Pelletier. “It’s gratifying to see that financial literacy is slowly becoming more of a priority in the states and in our nation’s capitol. We know that financial illiteracy was one of the causes of the Great Recession. Clearly, personal finance should be right up there with reading, writing and arithmetic as a critical subject.”

Pelletier also notes that studies demonstrate that financial literacy educational interventions in high school appear to have a positive impact on knowledge and measurable financial behaviors.

Illinois, Texas, Virginia, Washington state and West Virginia have enhanced financial literacy education of high school students since the 2015 report card. Arkansas, Delaware, Nevada and Vermont are in the process of making changes that could improve their overall grade once the proposed changes take effect.

Unfortunately, Louisiana abandoned its mandatory personal finance education requirement, and Idaho reduced the number of class hours required for the subject.

Only Utah earned an A+, while Alabama, Missouri, Tennessee and Virginia earned A grades. These states require students to take a standalone course.

Only six states earning a grade B clearly require 15 hours or more in personal finance instruction prior to high school graduation: Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New York, Texas and West Virginia (the other 13 grade B states require fewer than 15 hours of instruction or hours of instruction cannot be estimated). Only 11 states require high school students to receive 15 or more hours of financial instruction before entering the workforce or going to college.

Alaska, California, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Dakota and Wisconsin received an F grade. Louisiana, Montana, Vermont and Wyoming received a D grade.

Vermont Final Grade-D

Graduation Requirements

Is a high school course with personal finance concepts required to be taken as a graduation requirement? No, taking a course with personal finance concepts is not a graduation requirement. Local districts may offer a personal finance course, either on a stand-alone basis or embedded into another course offering. High school graduation requirements are determined by the local school districts. See: Vermont School Quality and Education Quality Standards (scroll to 2120.5 and then to 2120.7). 

Education Standards

In 2014, Vermont adopted Vermont Education Quality Standards (EQS) that require local school districts to deliver curriculum aligned to Vermont Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements (PBGRs) approved by the State Board of Education. Students are required to demonstrate proficiency in global citizenship (including the concepts of civics, economics, geography, world language, cultural studies and history). See: Vermont Global Citizenship Standards. Although global citizenship includes economics, it does not include financial literacy. In addition to the EQS and PBGRs, educational standards have been approved by the state's Board of Education that include some financial literacy topics. Modest but substantive personal finance and personal economics educational standards are included in the fall of 2000 Framework of Standards and Learning Opportunities. Most of the framework has been replaced by other curriculum content standards. Although modest portions of the framework are still applicable, these standards, including personal finance standards, have not been on Vermont's Content Areas website since December 2016. On August 30, 2017, the Vermont Board of Education authorized the Agency of Education to research and propose financial literacy standards. It is not clear if these financial literacy standards, when they are proposed and assuming Board of Education approval, will continue to be mandatory. If mandatory, Vermont's grade will increase to a grade C, and if voluntary, Vermont's grade will decline to a grade F.


It is not clear how Vermont measures student achievement in financial literacy or how the state monitors local school district implementation of the financial literacy education requirement. 

The Champlain College Center’s report card is based on research and personal interviews with state officials on their assessment policies, graduation requirements and educational standards. Here are the 2013 and 2015 report cards, as well as a 2016 adult report card.

Pelletier notes readers of the report card in a particular state could be miffed by a C, D or F grade when their particular school offers a personal finance course. He says there are many wonderful pockets of financial literacy excellence in every state, usually due to the efforts of principals, teachers, parents and others in the community, not the result of a state-wide required educational policy.

Source: BURLINGTON, Vt.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Center for Financial Literacy at Champlain College 12.12.2017